All I know is ? Both of the pistols the guy had, The D. Wesson and the Colt ? Were a friggin nightmare to appraise. The Wesson Co. has been bought at least twice since it started. The original pistols had subtle variations on the barrels that affected value, And SCOF had the pricing ALL screwed up.
Pricing over all 3 owners of the company was the same, And I KNOW that's bullshit.
The Colt ? All I know was it was a factory nickel, presentation grade, and worth a shitload. Colt wasn't even sure about it's history. The feller may have had a very valuable pistol if he'd had the history of the pistol.
All this research took a shitload of time, With no real value being able to be placed on either pistol. The D. Wesson was a rarer variation because of the barrel contour, and I never found another for sale exactly like it.
Had it been me ? I would have held on to both pistols. I could not find a exact pistol of either model on the net anywhere, and you can bet your ass I looked. Of the 2 ? The Colt was a friggin NIGHTMARE. There are several variations, With the differences being which way the frame checkering was placed. Where the barrel was measured from, All sorts of silly shit. It got to be mind boggling. I did learn one thing ? SCREW COLT !!
Double, You ain't busting my chops, I agree with you, I do the same thing...I've got a $3300 rifle sitting here that will never get shot, among others. When you buy high $$ firearms ? You just take a bigger risk that they will appreciate in value over time. Some do, Some are already at the value limit.
The $3300 Zanardini I bought ? I STILL don't know it's actual value. BUT ! From what I've researched ? It's the Italian version of a Holland & Holland. Hand made custom rifle. And I've still to find one for sale exactly like it. The ones I've found ? Lead me to believe it's worth MUCH more than what I've paid for it. Who the hell knows. The feller said it was his Dad's, and he bought it in Germany sometime around 1980 he thought.
All I know is the build is wonderful, Near a piece of art as you can get, without being gaudy.....